Why Are Aussie Beef Farmers Struggling While Supermarket Meat Prices Soar?

News

Why Are Aussie Beef Farmers Struggling While Supermarket Meat Prices Soar?

For decades, Australian families have watched the price of beef rise at the supermarket checkout. But behind the scenes, the story for the farmers who raise that beef is far less rosy—and the gap between what farmers earn and what you pay has never been wider.

The Reality for Australian Beef Farmers

According to the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences (ABARES), the average cash income for specialist beef farms dropped by a staggering 66% in 2023–24, falling to just $65,000 per farm—60% below the 10-year average. This dramatic fall comes after years of relatively flat incomes, even as costs for fuel, feed, and labour have risen sharply [ABARES][Beef Central].

While there were some good years—like a near doubling of farm incomes in 2014–15 due to strong export demand and higher cattle prices—these were the exception, not the rule [Beef Central].

Meanwhile, Supermarket Beef Prices Keep Rising

Despite the challenges faced by farmers, beef prices in Australian supermarkets have increased by more than 50% over the past decade. For example, retail beef prices rose from around $5.00 per kilo in 2016 to well over $7.00 per kilo by 2022, with further increases projected for 2024 and beyond [Selina Wamucii].

The biggest spike came between 2020 and 2022, when retail beef prices jumped by more than 16% in a single year—far outpacing the average cost of living increase [Beef Central].

Why the Disconnect?

So why aren’t farmers seeing the benefits of these higher prices? The answer lies in the structure of Australia’s meat supply chain:

Supermarkets have enormous buying power, often leaving farmers with little choice but to accept the prices offered.
Price transparency is lacking. According to Cattle Australia, producers often receive only a small portion of the final retail price, with little clarity on how prices are set at the supermarket level [Beef Central].
Price drops for livestock take months to reach consumers. When cattle prices fall, it can take up to eight months for those savings to appear at the checkout—if they appear at all [Beef Central].

The Result: Farmers Squeezed, Consumers Paying More

This system means that when times are tough, farmers feel the pain immediately, while supermarkets maintain their margins. Even as the price of cattle plummeted in 2023, supermarket prices barely budged, and the share of the retail dollar going to producers hit its lowest point in over 20 years [Beef Central].

Fixing the Broken System Starts with Fair Prices at the Source. When farmers are empowered to set their own rates, everything changes—from the ground up. Instead of chasing volume and cutting corners to meet supermarket demands, they can invest in long-term sustainability: better animal welfare, regenerative farming practices, and healthier, more diverse farms. We see more holistic land management, fewer antibiotics and hormones, and a shift toward quality over quantity. This ripple effect doesn’t stop on the farm—it reaches all the way to your plate. Consumers gain access to more transparent, nutrient-rich, ethically raised meat. The food system becomes more resilient, less centralized, and far more equitable. In short, giving farmers control over their pricing helps fix everything that’s currently broken: from environmental outcomes to public health to rural livelihoods.

There Is a Better Way: ButcherCrowd

ButcherCrowd was created as a direct response to this broken system. We believe in values over profits. That’s why ButcherCrowd allows farmers to set their own fair prices—reflecting the true cost of sustainable, ethical farming. By buying directly from the farm, you ensure more of your dollar goes to the people who actually raise your food.

Start by building your first box today

Support Aussie farmers. Get better value. Know exactly where your meat comes from.

Sources:

ButcherCrowd is better

BETTER FOR THE FARMING & FISHING FAMILIES, THE ANIMALS, THE ENVIRONMENT AND BETTER FOR YOU. A BETTER WAY OF EATING MEAT.

Build your box

SKIP, PAUSE OR CANCEL ANYTIME